Whenever you trade in the forex markets (except when you use a limit order) you will pay a spread – the difference between the bid and the ask price. This ought to make it easy to compare spreads among different forex brokers, but unfortunately it isn’t quite that easy . . . brokers employ one of a number of different execution models, and in order to make meaningful comparisons it is necessary to understand a little more about these.


ECN Brokers

An ECN is an ‘electronic communications network’, and is how banks and liquidity providers interact to exchange currencies. ECN brokers provide direct access to this interbank market, where spreads are extremely narrow, and charge a commission for doing so.

Quite often these brokers are keen to identify themselves as such, as there is some perception that the ECN model provides greater transparent and removes the potential for conflicts of interest (the broker makes their profit from the fixed commission they charge, and so have no motivation to game the spread in any way). However, interbank spreads are extremely sensitive to market volatility and liquidity shortages, and can become prohibitively wide during events such as news releases.

Dealing Desk Brokers

Brokers who operate a dealing desk model act as an immediate counter party to their client’s trades, and therefore control the bid-ask spread, and the spread is how they make their money. Because they make their profits from the inflated spread they do not charge commissions. Often, dealing desk brokers choose to provide ‘fixed spreads’, which means that the spread that you will be charged is guaranteed at a certain amount regardless of how wide or narrow the ‘floating spread’ in the underlying market may be.

STP Brokers

An STP or ‘straight-through-processing’ broker occupies the middle ground between the two models described above. An STP firm will pool the the best bids and offers from its liquidity providers, inflate this spread, and then enable you to trade at these prices. There is no dealing desk intervention and prices are based upon (though inflated from) those found in the interbank market; the spreads are therefore always floating and never fixed, and no commissions are charged.

And important first step when comparing brokers is therefore to identify which of the above categories a firm falls into. Then you can begin comparing them with similar companies to determine which will be the most suitable. Remember, however, that trading fees are by no means the most important priority when choosing a broker.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s